SimpliSafe vs. Vivint

Which home security system is a better choice for you? Compare SimpliSafe and Vivint side by side.

SimpliSafe (founded in 2006) and Vivint (founded in 1999) are relative newcomers to the home security world, but they are both leading service providers. Each company offers competitive features like modern equipment, 24/7 professional monitoring, and a variety of package options. While SimpliSafe is the more flexible option due to its do-it-yourself set up and month-to-month billing, Vivint’s advantages include professional installation and more robust home automation options.

Best for DIY Installation

SimpliSafe Security

  • No contracts
  • Inexpensive professional monitoring
  • A range of security packages

Best for Smart Homes

Vivint Security

  • Variety of smart home devices and features
  • Wireless system
  • Mobile app access and control available

Compare SimpliSafe vs. Vivint

SimpliSafe and Vivint are award-winning home security providers with a range of solutions that help customers protect their homes. Read on to understand how each company stacks up in terms of price, flexibility, equipment and more.

Installation

Winner: Vivint

Installation is a major point of differentiation between these two home security providers. Vivint requires professional installation – which typically costs $199 – while SimpliSafe systems are designed for do-it-yourself (DIY) installation. While DIY installation is great if you’re tech savvy and looking to save a few dollars, professional installation ensures the system is set up properly. During the installation process, you have the opportunity to ask questions about your system. If you’re looking for help at this crucial stage, Vivint is the way to go.

Price

Winner: SimpliSafe

When planning home security expenses, look at the total costs of equipment, monitoring services and any applicable one-time installation or activation fees. SimpliSafe beats out Vivint in all areas. SimpliSafe’s entry-level equipment package starts around $220 while Vivint requires a minimum of $650 in equipment to begin service. From there, SimpliSafe monitoring fees start at $14.99/mo. and Vivint starts at $38.99/mo. And don’t forget that there’s a fee associated with Vivint’s professional installation.

Home Automation

Winner: Vivint

Vivint takes the prize when it comes to home automation features. Vivint systems can include or integrate with more smart home devices than SimpliSafe. While SimpliSafe does have offerings in this department (such as motion-detecting cameras and Amazon Alexa support) Vivint presents more opportunities to control your smart devices and security system from one mobile app and panel.

Trial Period

Winner: SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe has a no-questions-asked 60-Day Money-Back Guarantee. You can use your system for up to two months. If it doesn’t fulfill your expectations, you can simply return it for a full refund within that trial period (prepaid return label included). On the other hand, Vivint has a 3-day period in which you can return your equipment without penalty, and there have been some complaints to the Better Business Bureau about the difficulty of cancelling the service.

Professional Monitoring

Tie: SimpliSafe and Vivint

Both SimpliSafe and Vivint offer their customers 24/7 professional monitoring. This means a team of trained professionals are ready to respond around-the-clock in the event of an emergency. Both providers also some form of video verification as well. If your alarms are activated, professionals at the monitoring center can see if there’s any suspicious activity detected on camera. SimpliSafe does allow you to buy their equipment without purchasing a monitoring plan, so you can use it as a self-monitored system if desired.

Security Cameras

Tie: SimpliSafe and Vivint

SimpliSafe and Vivint both have competitive security camera options. SimpliSafe only offers one indoor camera option, the SimpliCam, but it has several cutting-edge features such as night vision, HD resolution and two-way audio. It also has a pet-friendly motion detection feature capable of identifying the heat signatures of humans, so there aren’t false alarms every time your dog moves from the couch to the bed. Vivint offers a few more camera options: the Ping indoor camera, an intruder-sending outdoor camera and a video doorbell. Keep in mind that the cameras drive up equipment pricing for both providers.

Differences: SimpliSafe vs. Vivint

If you’ve narrowed down your home security choices to SimpliSafe and Vivint, your decision will likely come down to either price priorities or installation preferences. Compared to Vivint, SimpliSafe is the most cost-effective professionally monitored system with a flexible DIY model. However, Vivint will send a technician to your home to get everything in working order. Vivint also offers a more comprehensive smart home safety suite with several devices.

Research SimpliSafe Research Vivint

SimpliSafe Security

Learn more
Monthly monitoring starting price $38.99/mo.
Contract length 36 months
Trial period 3 days
BBB rating D-

Frequently Asked Questions about SimpliSafe and Vivint

FAQ-desktop

Do SimpliSafe and Vivint provide professional installation?

Vivint provides professional installation for its security systems, but SimpliSafe allows you to self-install your security system. Vivint’s installation service is $199.

Does SimpliSafe security require a contract?

SimpliSafe’s services do not require a long-term contract. You’ll have to pay for your equipment up front and can opt to pay for professional monitoring on a monthly basis.

Does Vivint security require a contract?

Historically, Vivint has required long-term contracts with a minimum duration of 36 months.

What types of equipment packages do SimpliSafe and Vivint provide?

SimpliSafe offers a number of equipment packages to choose from to include the basic, Foundation Package, Essentials Package, Haven Package and the Hearth Package. With the basic package, you’ll get the base station, keypad, an entry sensor and a motion sensor. Vivint does not have pre-set equipment packages. Instead, you pick and choose the devices that are right for your home and priorities. You pay for Vivint equipment up front and then a monhtly monitoring fee for the duration of your contract.

What professional monitoring options do SimpliSafe and Vivint have?

Professional monitoring for both providers varies depending on the package and service selected. SimpliSafe’s professional monitoring costs between $14.99- $24.99 monthly, while Vivint’s monitoring services start at $38.99/mo. If you add video surveillance to your Vivint plan, it costs an additional $5/mo. per camera.


Jalesa Campbell

Written by your home security specialist

Jalesa Campbell