Brinks vs. Smith Thompson

Compare Brinks and Smith Thompson to see which security system is the right one for you.

Brinks vs. Smith Thompson

Brinks and Smith Thompson both offer their clients competitive rates, 24/7 professional monitoring, and a wide range of security equipment. Brinks offers both DIY and professional installation services and a 30-day money-back guarantee. Smith Thompson gives clients a professional installation service and a flexible month-to-month service plan. It also provides a range of home automation devices such as temperature and light controls for extra security. It is worth noting that Smith Thompson only serves Texas residents – so that must be considered before everything else. See what these providers can offer you to keep your home safe.

Compare Brinks vs. Smith Thompson

Compare Brinks vs. Smith Thompson

(D) Brinks vs Smith Thompson

Installation

Winner: Brinks

With both DIY and professional installation available, Brinks wins this round. As Brinks equipment is small and lightweight, it is easy to move. It also offers free installation. Smith Thompson, on the other hand, offers professional installation only, which costs $89.

Equipment

Winner: Smith Thompson

Smith Thompson wins this round as it has a wider range of home security and automation devices. Both companies offer a comprehensive range of security equipment, including control panels, motion sensors and security cameras. Brinks offers the essentials, home environmental monitoring, and smart home devices, but the provider has a smaller selection compared to Smith Thompson.

Trial Period

Winner: Brinks

With a 30-day money-back guarantee and no termination fees, Brinks wins this round. Smith Thompson’s 3-day trial period, offers users very little time to try out its system.

Home Automation

Winner: Smith Thompson

Smith Thompson offers a range of home automation devices as an option with each package. It also offers several smart home products for lock, temperature and light control. Brinks has a smaller selection of smart home devices to choose from, but you can use Nest smart devices if you purchase the Nest Secure system.

Price

Tie: Brinks and Smith Thompson

Both providers have security systems with relatively low-upfront costs that are between $200 – $400. You can get a security system for as low as $299 with Smith Thompson and one for as low as $199 with Brinks. Professional monitoring is also inexpensive to average — monitoring starts at $16.95/mo., for Smith Thompson and $19/mo. with Brinks. One of the biggest differences you’ll find involves contracts. Smith Thompson doesn’t require signing a contract at all, but Brinks will require a 36-month contract.

Mobile Apps

Tie: Brinks and Smith Thompson

It’s a close call here. Both Brinks and Smith Thompson have mobile apps that allow you to arm/disarm your security system, control smart home devices, view cameras, and more. To access mobile app control, you will have to choose a higher tier monitoring plan with Smith Thompson, but you’re free to use Brinks’ mobile app with any monitoring plan or Brinks package that you choose.

Summary: Brinks vs. Smith Thompson

Smith Thompson offers a wider variety of equipment than Brinks and slightly beats Brinks with a lower starting monitoring price. One thing to remember with Smith Thompson is that their service is only available to Texas residents. Brinks’ professional and self-installation options give its clients more choices. Furthermore, its longer trial period gives customers more time to try out their security system. We believe that both have a solid tie, but Smith Thompson is better suited for local Texas residents looking for an affordable provider, while Brinks is better suited for customers who prefer flexibility with their security system and lower upfront costs.

Brinks Home Security

Learn more about
Monthly monitoring starting price $19/mo. $16.95/mo.
Minimum contract length 36 months No contract
Extended No-Risk Return 30 days 3 days
Installation DIY & Professional Professional
Guarantees None $500 Theft Protection
Warranty 2-year equipment warranty 1-year on parts and labor
BBB Rating A+ A+
Frequently Asked Questions About Brinks and Smith Thompson

Frequently Asked Questions About Brinks and Smith Thompson

What kind of equipment packages do Brinks and Smith Thompson offer?

Both Brinks and Smith Thompson offer a wide range of security equipment. Brinks offers one Nest Guard, two Nest Detect motion sensors, and two Nest tags with the Nest Secure System. For Brinks’ Smart Security Essential Package, you’ll get a control panel, sensors, and signage. Smith Thompson’s basic package offers a control panel, sensors, siren, a wireless transmitter, and signage.

What kind of monitoring plans do Brinks and Smith Thompson offer?

Professional monitoring is available from both Brinks and Smith Thompson. Brinks professional monitoring starts at $19/mo., and Smith Thompson begins at $16.95/mo.

Do either Brinks or Smith Thompson offer the ability to self-monitor your own security system, or is professional monitoring required?

Both professional monitoring and self-monitoring are available with Brinks. Smith Thompson only offers 24/7 professional monitoring.

Are either Brinks or Smith Thompson a good choice for renters?

Smith Thompson does not offer a DIY installation option, and the equipment cannot be moved once it is installed. Brinks is more suitable for renters as a DIY installation option is available, and the security system can be easily moved.


safety logo

Researched by the

Safety Team

The Safety Team is a group of experts that handle provider research, product reviews and recalls to make your home safety and security search as easy as 1-2-3.