Brinks vs. Protection 1

Compare Brinks and Protection 1 to choose the home security company that’s best for you.

Brinks vs. Protection 1

If you’ve narrowed your home security search down to Brinks and Protection 1, let us help you make your final choice with some details about the two companies. Both of these providers are reputable companies offering standard home security services such as entry detection, 24/7 professional monitoring and security cameras. While similar, they have some distinct differences. We’ll lay those differences out to help you make your decision.

Compare Brinks vs. Protection 1

Compare Brinks vs. Protection 1

Brinks and Protection 1 are both large, national security companies with a reputation for great customer service, and both serve over a million customers. Brinks is by far the most experienced security company, operating for more than 160 years in various security-related endeavors, and entering into home security in 1983. Protection 1, meanwhile, is a little younger, but its dedication to customer service is second to none. To demonstrate this, the company did away with its automated answering service in order to better connect to its customers. Both companies offer an array of home security products and services under a long-term contract, and both offer both do-it-yourself and professional installation, but there are some differences in their pricing models.

Price

Winner: Brinks

Brinks offers 24/7 professional monitoring starting at $39.99 per month, and even lower for Nest customers that want Brinks professional monitoring at $29.99 per month. Whereas Protection 1’s lowest price per month is $34.99, and its monitoring service can be up to $54.99 per month, which is comparatively steep. However, Protection 1’s monthly pricing structure includes equipment costs.

Equipment Cost

Winner: Protection 1

While both services have a good selection of security equipment including entry detection, cameras, and control pads at an affordable price, there’s no upfront cost for equipment with Protection 1. Brinks equipment, on the other hand, costs $199 for the most basic package, and usually more if you’d like to add video doorbell or security cameras – costing up to $1,099.

Monitoring

Winner: Brinks

Brinks and Protection 1 both require 24/7 professional monitoring to protect your home. However, Brinks offers both self and professional monitoring for Nest customers starting at $19 per month with a three-year contract, or $29.99 per month for month-to-month monitoring. Since Brinks offers both DIY and professional options depending on your equipment choice this category goes to them.

Warranty

Winner: Brinks

Protection 1 offers a $1,000 Theft Protection Guarantee, a generous offer that very few companies match. Brinks does offer a 2-year equipment warranty and $500 in theft protection, but Protection 1’s wins thanks to its bigger promise.

Home Automation

Winner: Brinks

Both Protection 1 and Brinks offer some smart home capabilities including smart light control and connectivity to your voice assistant. However, Brinks’ offerings in this area are more robust at a lower cost, with mobile control already included in its basic package. Protection 1 only offers this kind of capability with its two highest-priced packages.

Safety Monitoring

Tie: Brinks & Protection 1

On all its plans, Protection 1 offers monitored fire and carbon monoxide protection, as well as what it calls “environmental and life safety,” which means monitoring for extreme temperatures or flooding, as well as a medical panic button. Brinks offers LiveVoice Assist and a similar array of environmental monitoring services – making this category a tie.

Winner: Brinks

When all is said and done, these two home security companies really are neck and neck. Both have a great reputation, dedication to customer service, and a complete line of services, including 24/7 home, environmental and medical monitoring. Protection 1’s $1000 Theft Protection Guarantee is a compelling offer, but Brinks better pricing and longer experience win out for most situations.

Brinks Home Security

Learn more about
Monitoring costs starting at $29.99/mo. $34.99/mo.
Contract length 36 months 36 months
Trial period 30 days None
Installation (DIY or Pro) DIY with professional option Professional
Guarantees None $1,000 Theft Protection Guarantee
Warranty 2-year equipment warranty None
BBB Rating A+ A+
Please note that BBB ratings, plans, pricing, and other details can change without our knowledge. Details accurate as of May 26, 2020.
Frequently Asked Questions about Brinks and Protection 1

Frequently Asked Questions about Brinks and Protection 1

What kind of equipment packages do Brinks and Protection 1 offer?

Brinks offers three basic equipment packages, including the Essential, Complete and Ultimate packages, plus its Nest package. The most basic Essential package includes a touchscreen controller, wireless motion sensor, two wireless door sensors, yard signs and stickers. Protection 1 equipment is included in the cost of monitoring packages and includes items such as motion detectors, window and door sensors, carbon monoxide and smoke detectors, panic buttons, and control panels.

What kind of monitoring plans do Brinks and Protection 1 offer?

24/7 monitoring with Brinks costs $39.99 per month at the lowest, with a three-year contract, and Protection 1’s monitoring service starts at $34.99 per month, also with a three-year contract and no upfront equipment cost.

Do either Brinks or Protection 1 offer the ability to self-monitor your own security system, or is professional monitoring required?

Brinks offers a self-monitoring option through its partner, Nest. Protection 1 does not offer a self-monitoring option

Are either Brinks or Protection 1 a good choice for renters?

Brinks systems are fully wireless, as are Protection 1’s. Brinks offers both professional and DIY installation, whereas Protection 1 only offers professional installation. This means your system can move, so renters should have no problem utilizing either of these services.


safety logo

Researched by the

Safety Team

The Safety Team is a group of experts that handle provider research, product reviews and recalls to make your home safety and security search as easy as 1-2-3.