Brinks vs. Protect America

Compare Brinks and Protect America to find the home security provider that is right for you.

Brinks and Protect America are home security providers that offer clients with 24/7 professional monitoring services, a mobile app, and competitive prices. While similar, there are some differences between them that can help you decide. Compare these home security providers to see which one is the best for you.

Best for Flexible Installation

Best Entry-Level Pricing

  • Price-match guarantee
  • Smart home devices and features
  • Mobile app access & control

Compare Brinks vs. Protect America

Brinks and Protect America both offer their clients a comprehensive range of home security and automation equipment and 24/7 professional monitoring. Brinks does not require a contract and provides a two-year warranty on all devices. Protect America offers clients a DIY installation option, and equipment is available with no upfront fee. Like Brinks, it also provides a mobile app that allows clients to control their security and home automation systems, while also viewing live security camera footage. See what these providers can offer you to make sure your home is safe.


Winner: Protect America

With competitive professional monitoring rates and no upfront equipment cost, Protect America wins this category. Professional installation starts at $19.99/mo. and could vary based on your package. On the other hand, Brinks requires no contract for its Nest plan, and its professional monitoring starts at $29.99/mo.. Professional monitoring starts at $19.99/mo., and a 36-month contract is required. Most Brinks equipment starts at $399 and could call for a $199 upfront.

Professional Monitoring

Winner: Brinks

Brinks’ basic Nest security system is available without a contract. However, if you choose any other plan outside of the Nest option, you will need to sign a 36-month contract. Protect America, on the other hand, requires a 36-month service agreement for all packages. Brinks’ flexibility gives it the edge in this category.

Mobile App

Tie: Brinks & Protect America

Both mobile apps offer similar features, such as instant alerts if your security system has been triggered. You can also connect and control smart home devices, lock and unlock your smart lock, control home automation devices, and view live security camera footage. Either company is a great choice for mobile app functionality.


Winner: Protect America

With its basic package, Brinks offers cellular backup, smartphone control, motion detection and door/window sensors. Home automation and video recording are available at an additional charge. Protect America provides a standard control panel, one motion sensor, and three window/door sensors with its basic package. Extra security and home equipment can be added to the package at an additional charge. Brinks requires $199 upfront for equipment, but Protect America does not require an upfront payment, making it the winner of this category. 

Warranty & Guarantees

Winner: Protect America

Brinks offers its clients a two-year warranty on all devices. Protect America provides better warranties and guarantees with a free lifetime warranty on equipment and a Price Match Guarantee.


Winner: Brinks

Brinks wins out in this category due to its flexibility. Brinks offers both DIY and professional installation while Protect America requires that customers install the system themselves.

Summary: Brinks vs. Protect America

Brinks offers its clients a wide range of security equipment and professional installation, all with no contract once you choose the Nest option. Both Brinks and Protect America offer a mobile app that allows clients to view security camera footage and control home automation devices. Protect America also provides its clients a free lifetime warranty on all devices and a price-match guarantee, making Protect America the winner of this contest.

Brinks Protect America

Brinks Home Security

Learn more about
Monthly monitoring starting price $29.99/mo. $19.99/mo.
Minimum contract length 36 months 36 months
Extended No-Risk Return 30 days 15-day return policy for a full refund
Installation DIY & Professional DIY
Guarantees None Price Match Guarantee
Warranty 2-Year Warranty Free Lifetime Equipment Warranty
BBB Rating A+ A+
Safety Score 8.2 7.2

Frequently Asked Questions About Brinks and Protect America


What kind of equipment packages do Brinks and Protect America offer?

Brinks offers two Nest Tags, two Nest Detect motion sensors and one Nest Guard with its basic Nest package. Brinks’ package includes 24/7 monitoring, sensors, motion detection, smartphone control and a touchscreen control panel. Protect America provides a standard control, one motion sensor, and three window/door sensors with its basic package. 

What kind of monitoring plans do Brinks and Protect America offer?

Both Brinks and Protect America offer 24/7 professional monitoring, with Brinks’ basic package starting at $19.99/mo. with a three-year contract and Protect America’s basic monitoring package starting at $19.99/mo. 

Do either Brinks or Protect America offer the ability to self-monitor your own security system, or is professional monitoring required?

Neither Protect America or Brinks offer the ability to self-monitor. They both, however, offer security cameras and doorbell cameras at an additional charge that can be viewed from either control panels or mobile apps. 

Are either Brinks or Protect America a good choice for renters?

Both have a DIY option, which is a plus. Brinks’ Nest plan is the best overall option for renters, since it doesn’t require a contract.

safety logo

Researched by the

Safety Team

The Safety Team is a group of experts that handle provider research, product reviews and recalls to make your home safety and security search as easy as 1-2-3.