Safety.com is an independent review site. Advertising helps our insights remain free. We may receive a fee when you click on links on our site. View advertiser disclosure.
Best home security system quiz | Our team of security experts will guide you to the best security systems for your unique needs
Brinks and Bay Alarm have some significant similarities in terms of their reputations and contracts. However, some major differences exist. Brinks offers nationwide service, whereas Bay Alarm is only available to residents in California and specific areas of Washington and Arizona. For homeowners living in these areas, it’s worth investigating the pros and cons of both companies.
Compare Brinks vs. Bay Alarm
With Brinks, you'll enjoy a more affordable price and easier installation but sacrifice the ability to customize your equipment package. You might pay more for Bay Alarm, but in exchange, this home security provider offers complete customization and hands-on support services. See how the two providers stack up across six major categories.
Price
Winner: Brinks
Brinks offers bundled equipment packages starting at $299 for the Essentials and topping out at $1,099 for the Smart Security Ultimate bundle. Brinks' monitoring fees also vary based on your chosen equipment package and range from $19.99 per month with a three-year Nest contract to $39 per month for the Smart Security Ultimate package. On the other hand, Bay Alarm prefers to take a custom approach to assemble each customer's ideal equipment package and therefore does not offer transparent pricing. However, Bay Alarm's monthly monitoring starts at $35 per month.
Contract
Winner: Brinks
Both Brinks and Bay Alarm cater to homeowners who are confident they want a long-term security solution. Expect a minimum 36-month contract when signing up with both Brinks and Bay Alarm. However, if you choose the Nest package with Brinks monitoring, you can choose to pay month to month, or sign up for a 36-month contract and receive a discount.
Warranty
Winner: Brinks
What happens if your equipment breaks? A warranty ensures you can expect your equipment to function smoothly for a specified period of time, and if it doesn't, you'll receive a free replacement. The longer the warranty, the better. With Bay Alarm your warranty lasts one year. Brinks offers a longer warranty that lasts two years.
Installation
Winner: Brinks
All of Brinks' equipment is designed for easy DIY installation right out of the box. Once you decide where you'd like to place all of the monitors, sensors or cameras, you can peel back the adhesive covering and stick them to virtually any surface. All that's left is to call Brinks to activate the monitoring service. If you'd prefer to have a professional come to your home to help you set up and place the equipment, you can also do that through Brinks. On the other hand, Bay Alarm requires professional installation and charges a $199 installation fee. Since Brinks gives you an option between both installation options they win this round.
Trial Period
Winner: Bay Alarm
Considering that each of these home security providers has a long contract, a generous trial period can help you feel truly confident in the equipment and monitoring service before you make a long-term commitment. Brinks offers a 30-day trial period, whereas Bay Alarm allows you to try out the equipment and receive a full refund if returned within 90-days.
Mobile App
Tie: Brinks & Bay Alarm
Bay Alarm and Brinks both place significant emphasis on home automation and the ability to remotely control your home system. Both companies offer highly-rated mobile apps that allow you to view live video feeds, adjust the thermostat and control other smart equipment. With similar customer ratings (Brinks' mobile app has 4.2 stars and Bay Alarm's has 4.3) and functionality, neither company is a clear winner in this category.
Winner: Brinks
Despite the similarities between Brinks and Bay Alarm, Brinks ultimately offers greater flexibility and affordability. However, if you live within Bay Alarm's service area and want a long-term security contract with professional installation, monitoring and equipment consultation, then Bay Alarm still represents an excellent choice.
Please note that BBB ratings, plans, pricing, and other details can change without our knowledge. Details accurate as of May 26, 2020.
Frequently Asked Questions About Brinks vs. Bay Alarm
Brinks offers four equipment packages: Nest Secure, Smart Security Essential, Smart Security Complete and Smart Security Ultimate. Bay Alarm does not offer equipment packages, but customizes everything based on the customer’s needs.
Brinks’ monitoring plans start at $29.99 per month its Nest Secure plan is available at $19.99 per month when purchased on a three-year contract. Brinks’ home security monitoring for its equipment costs $39 per month.
Professional monitoring is a requirement for all packages from both Brinks and Bay Alarm.
Because Brinks’ peel-and-stick wireless installation is easy to take with you when you move, and it also offers a no-contract option with its Nest package, Brinks is the better choice for renters.
What is the best home security package for you?
Use our Package Finder to find the right package based on your home security needs!
The Safety Team is a group of experts that handle provider research, product reviews and recalls to make your home safety and security search as easy as 1-2-3.
