ADT vs. Protection 1

Compare ADT and Protection 1 to find the right security solution for your home

ADT vs. Protection 1

ADT and Protection 1 provide home security solutions and 24/7 professional monitoring. ADT is a leading home security company with lengthy industry experience and a 6-month money-back guarantee. Protection 1, now owned by ADT, offers customers a $1,000 theft-protection guarantee and a wide range of home security and automation equipment. See what these providers have to offer to suit your home security needs.

Compare ADT vs. Protection 1

Compare ADT vs. Protection 1

(D) ADT vs Protection 1

Trial Period

Winner: ADT

ADT may own Protection 1, but Protection 1 doesn’t compete with its parent company here. ADT offers its clients a 6-month money-back guarantee that will give you time to see if it’s the right home security company for you. Protection 1 does not have a trial period.

Guarantees

Winner: Protection 1

ADT is known for its $500 Theft Protection guarantee, which provides customers with a $500 insurance deductible if their home is burglarized while using ADT’s security service. However, Protection 1 ups the ante with its highly competitive $1,000 Theft Protection Guarantee.

Price

Tie: ADT and Protection 1

ADT and Protection 1 are tied in price. ADT’s basic package is $35.99/mo. This includes 24/7 professional monitoring and home environmental monitoring. It also provides a digital panel, alarm and sensors. Protection 1’s basic package is $34.99/mo. This package includes 24/7 professional monitoring, a keypad, door contacts, and a motion detector.

Contract

Tie: ADT and Protection 1

These companies are neck-and-neck in the length of their contracts, too. Both require a 36-month contract. If you don’t mind the contract, either could be good options for you. But, if you’re a renter or plan on changing your residence more often, we would recommend choosing one of these DIY home security providers.

Mobile App

Tie: ADT and Protection 1

ADT’s mobile app allows clients to arm, disarm and control their security system from their mobile device. This is not available with the basic package, though. Protection 1 wins this round with its mobile app. Not only does it do everything that ADT’s app does, but it also controls home door locks and temperature, among other home automation features.

Equipment

Tie: ADT and Protection 1

Both ADT and Protection 1 offer clients a comprehensive range of home security equipment, including security cameras, smart locks, smart thermostats, a touchscreen control panel and more. You’ll have to pay more to access these features with both providers as they’re not available in the basic packages.

Differences: ADT vs. Protection 1

Differences: ADT vs. Protection 1

ADT and Protection 1 offer similarly priced packages and a 36-month contract. The cost of monitoring is also comparable between both providers. Both companies offer professional installation, and Protection 1 offers DIY installation. However, ADT offers more with a 6-month money-back guarantee for your customer satisfaction.
Monthly monitoring starting price $35.99/mo. $34.99/mo.
Minimum contract length 36 months 36 months
Trial Period 6 months None
Installation Professional Professional
BBB Rating A+ A+
Frequently Asked Questions About ADT and Protection 1

Frequently Asked Questions About ADT and Protection 1

What kind of equipment packages do ADT and Protection 1 offer?

ADT provides a digital panel, alarm and sensors with its basic package. Its most expensive package also includes an indoor camera or video doorbell camera and smartphone support with the ADT mobile app.

Protection 1 provides a touchscreen control panel, three door/window sensors and a motion sensor with its basic package. If you want to have more control over your security system, additional equipment like emergency buttons and outdoor cameras can be purchased at an additional cost.

What kind of monitoring plans do ADT and Protection 1 offer?

Protection 1 offers four separate packages ranging from $34.99/mo. to $54.99/mo. Its basic package monitors your home, fire and carbon monoxide and environmental safety, while its most expensive package also includes video surveillance, energy and home automation, and a camera-integrated motion detector.

ADT offers three packages ranging from $35.99/mo. to $57.99/mo. All packages include motion detection and home environmental monitoring, with more expensive packages also offering additional home device control.

Do either ADT or Protection 1 offer the ability to self-monitor your own security system, or is professional monitoring required?

Professional monitoring is required with both ADT and Protection 1 for their services.

Are either ADT or Protection 1 a good choice for renters?

We would recommend Protection 1 for renters since they will have the ability to self-install their security system. The only downside is that they will be tied to a 36-month contract. For renters who would prefer to avoid a contract, we’d recommend considering other DIY home security providers.


safety logo

Researched by the

Safety Team

The Safety Team is a group of experts that handle provider research, product reviews and recalls to make your home safety and security search as easy as 1-2-3.