Best Parent-Approved Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$196.90

Why we picked it:

  • Bed bug and dust mite resistant
  • Easy to clean with a damp cloth or sponge to quickly remove messes
  • Made with non-toxic materials for a safe, healthy sleep

Best Designed Crib Mattress

Nook Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$195.00

Why we picked it:

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a dual-sided sleep system
  • Made free of harsh chemicals and toxins to keep your baby safe
  • Waterproof, flame resistant crib mattress with machine washable wrap

Best Infant to Toddler Crib Mattress

Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$183.99

Why we picked it:

  • Fights snugly into standard cribs to reduce risks and sleep hazards including the baby’s arms and legs getting stuck
  • Designed to meet both infant and toddler sleep needs with dual-sleep sides to fit both infant and toddler beds
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty

5 Best Baby Mattresses of 2019

  • Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress – Best Parent-Approved
  • Nook Crib Mattress – Best Designed Mattress
  • Colgate Dual Firmness Mattress – Best Infant to Toddler Mattress
  • Newton Baby Crib Mattress – Most Green Materials
  • LULLABY EARTH Crib Mattress – Easiest Mattress to Clean




Factors to Consider Before Buying a Crib Mattress


Compare Baby Mattresses: Our Top 15 Picks

Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress

Best Parent-Approved Crib Mattress

1. Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$196.90

Description:

This Moonlight Slumber crib mattress grows with your baby to the toddler stage with a dual-sided sleep system. The mattress is made with high-density foam for infancy stages and certified CertiPUR-US foam. Simply clean this mattress with a damp cloth to easily wipe away any messes without leaving any stains. It’s designed without flame retardants and is made with double-stretch knit fabric for a long-lasting crib mattress. *Although Moonlight Slumber’s website does not list polyurethane as an included material, Safety.com experts contacted a Moonlight Slumber representative who confirmed that polyurethane is a material used for the mattress to be waterproof.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes SafeSewn seams to be dust mite and bed bug resistant
  • Waterproof, flame resistant and hypoallergenic
Learn More
Nook Crib Mattress

Best Designed Crib Mattress

2. Nook Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$195.00

Description:

The Nook Sleep Pebble Air is an all-in-one crib mattress that doesn’t require a mattress pad or cover. Its light-as-a-feather design keeps the mattress breathable to help your baby sleep comfortably. The mattress includes zinc guards to protect your baby against any built up germs for a clean and safe mattress. The Pebble Air comes in three colors to find the best fit your nursery design.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a dual-sided sleep system
  • Made free of harsh chemicals and toxins to keep your baby safe
  • Waterproof, flame resistant crib mattress with machine washable wrap
Learn More
Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Best Infant to Toddler Crib Mattress

3. Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$183.99

Description:

This Colgate crib mattress fits all standard cribs and toddler beds. The light and airy mattress design make it easy to flip when your infant grows into a toddler. It’s made with sustainable plant oils and meets safety requirements from the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) to keep your baby safe from flammable materials.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Made with Certified Organic cotton mattress cover and CertiPUR certified safe foam
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
Learn More
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

4. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$69.99

Description:

This Newton Baby light crib mattress is made with 100 percent recyclable materials. It’s designed to fit most standard cribs for a light, safe sleep. The Newton mattress uses Breathe-Thru Technology to reduce the risk of suffocation and breathing carbon dioxide by allowing the mattress’ air to flow freely. This mattress comes in four colors to best fit your nursery design.

Key Features

  • Designed with an air core for air to easily pass for a light, breathable sleep
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Designed with a washable 3D spacer cover to reduce the worry of stains or mold while allowing air to flow freely
Learn More
LULLABY EARTH Baby Crib Mattress

5. LULLABY EARTH Baby Crib Mattress

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$259.00

Description:

The Lullaby Earth crib mattress is flat with firm edges to fit standard cribs safely. It’s made to allow air to flow 360-degree under your infant with ease. The crib mattress is created with firm edges to avoid your baby from getting stuck in the space between the mattress and crib frame. Simply wash the removable mattress pad to remove any messes without any stains left behind.

Key Features

  • Designed with 3D fabric to allow mattress air to flow freely
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Waterproof and flame resistant crib mattress
Learn More
Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

6. Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Rating:

4.5

Cost:

$56.99

Description:

This long-lasting Milliard crib mattress is designed with five inches of high-quality foam to avoid it sinking over time. It includes a mattress cover that easily wipes away stains and messes. The mattress was made with your infant’s safety in mind – free of toxins and harsh chemicals for safe and serene sleeping.

Key Features

  • Designed with a density of 28D to keep your infant from sinking into the crib mattress and prevent SIDS
  • Includes a removable, waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress

    Waterproof and flame resistant crib mattress

Learn More
Safety 1st Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

7. Safety 1st Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$57.88

Description:

Safety 1st designed this lightweight crib mattress with high-quality foam to prevent your infant from sinking while sleeping. The mattress is water and flame resistant to keep your baby safe and sound while sleeping. This mattress comes in three colors to best fit your nursery design.

Key Features

  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a 100% vinyl mattress cover that easily wipes away stains and messes
  • 5-year limited warranty
Learn More
Sealy Toddler and Baby Crib Mattress

8. Sealy Toddler and Baby Crib Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$72.07

Description:

The Sealy crib mattress uses 150 steel coils and border rods to fit your crib for your baby to sleep safely. The mattress is designed with four layers for a firm, safe slumber. It includes a waterproof mattress cover to withstand water, moisture and mildew.

Key Features

  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Uses lock-stitched binding to protect the crib mattress from odors and stains
  • 10-year warranty
Learn More
Graco Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

9. Graco Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$59.99

Description:

This Graco crib mattress is made with five inches high-quality foam. It’s made with a polyurethane foam base for light and airy sleep. It’s made free from chemicals including phthalates and lead for a safe crib mattress that works for both infant and toddler growth stages. Graco’s crib mattress fits into a lightweight box to easily unpack for your convenience.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes a removable, waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
Learn More
Dream On Me Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

10. Dream On Me Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$78.48

Description:

This Dream On Me 2-in-1 crib mattress is easy to clean messes and stains with only warm water and soap. It’s designed for both infants and toddlers with six inches of firm foam and one inch of light and comfy foam for newborns to sleep happily and safely. The crib mattress cover is waterproof and hypoallergenic to reduce the worry of mold and mildew over time.

Key Features

  • Meets Federal Flammability Standards by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals

    15-year warranty

Learn More
Beautyrest 2-in-1 Crib and Toddler Mattress

11. Beautyrest 2-in-1 Crib and Toddler Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$143.15

Description:

The Beautyrest crib mattress uses 231 high-quality coil springs for a night of safe, firm sleep. Flip the mattress when your baby grows for toddlers to sleep safely with foam. The mattress is hypoallergenic to reduce the worry of mold and mildew in the mattress. It also includes a fire resistant wrap to protect the mattress and your baby.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • GREENGUARD GOLD and CertiPUR-US Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a woven, waterproof mattress cover with a stain-resistant design
Learn More
Kolcraft Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress

12. Kolcraft Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$47.99

Description:

The Kolcraft Pure Sleep crib mattress is designed to grow with your infant to the toddler years using a dual-sleep design. It’s made with 150 high-quality coils to avoid the common concern of your baby sinking into the mattress. This mattress’ design makes it easy to clean with a damp cloth to remove and messes or stains for your baby to enjoy their sleep.

Key Features

  • GREENGUARD GOLD and CertiPUR-US Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a breathable, easy to clean waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • 10-year warranty
Learn More
My Green Mattress Crib Mattress

13. My Green Mattress Crib Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

$279.00

Description:

This Emily crib mattress is made with a natural, 100% organically processed, and made with eco wool. The mattress can easily be flipped to prevent too much wear and tear on one side for a long-lasting crib mattress. It’s free of polyurethane foams to avoid the risk of your infant being exposed to toxins and harmful chemicals during sleep.

Key Features

  • Made with Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) cotton and 150 high-quality coil springs
  • Lead-free certified by the UL Laboratories for a crib mattress free of harsh chemicals
  • 10-year warranty
Learn More
Babyletto Non-Toxic Crib Mattress

14. Babyletto Non-Toxic Crib Mattress

Rating:

4

Cost:

Description:

The Babyletto Pure Core mattress was designed with your baby’s safety in mind. It is a vegan, non-toxic crib mattress free of flame retardants or dyes. The mattress has both a firm and soft side to match your baby’s sleep needs from infant to toddler growth stages for many nights of free of harsh chemicals when sleeping.

Key Features

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes a vinyl-free, removable, easy to clean waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • 10-year warranty
Learn More
Naturepedic Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

15. Naturepedic Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Rating:

3.5

Cost:

$299.00

Description:

The Naturepedic crib mattress uses 150 heavy-duty coils for infants to have firm support while sleeping. It includes square corners for your baby to sleep safely without risk of arms or legs getting stuck in tight corners. The crib mattress is made from a GOTS-certified brand that only uses GOTS-approved materials for your baby’s safety.

Key Features

  • Made with 100% USA organic cotton fabric and GOTS-certified materials
  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Square edges for the crib mattress to fit tightly and securely into any standard crib
Learn More

Viewing 10 of 15 products


Exploring the Different Types of Crib Mattresses

Coil crib mattress

Coil crib mattresses are designed with metal coils to be firm and to help to reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome or suffocation as they do not conform to the baby’s body. For your newborn’s safety, look for an high-density firm foam or coil crib mattress that has at least 150 coils for it be firm enough for your baby. Coil crib mattresses can be more costly than foam mattresses specially designed for infants, but often provide more support and comfortable layers that won’t reduce the coil crib mattress firmness.

Foam crib mattress

Foam crib mattresses are often made to be airy and lightweight for a cloud-like sleep. They’re designed for toddlers who no longer require the firm mattress design that infants do. A foam mattress should only be used for toddlers because they can increase the risk of suffocation if the mattress forms to your baby’s head and body. Foam crib mattresses are often made with organic materials and are more cost-effective that innerspring crib mattresses.

Double-sided

Double-sided crib mattresses are the best-valued mattress for your baby because you can use the same mattress during both infant and toddler growth stages. One side is designed to be firm with coils or high-density foam and extra support for your baby during infancy. And once your baby is a little older, you’ll be able to flip the mattress over for a cushion-like feel that’s designed for their age and development. Double-sided crib mattresses are often more expensive but are often the best value over time.     


Crib Mattress FAQs

Do I need a crib mattress for my infant?

For your baby’s health and safety, you need a crib mattress for your baby. While most parents may use bassinets or sleep with their babies, these are not the safest sleeping options for babies as they develop. Remember that babies need firm support when sleeping for their healthy spine, bone and body development. When your baby grows into a toddler or at least 35 inches, you’ll have more free range to choose different mattress options.

Can I use a second hand crib mattress?

Buying a secondhand crib mattress may be a cheaper option, but it’s not always the safest. A second hand crib mattress can come with many sanitary concerns such as trapped mold, mildew or stains. Also over time, a used mattress may not be as safe as it could have worn out springs or shrinkage which could be a concern for your baby. Also, remember that older crib mattresses may not fit today’s standard crib size.

How long does a crib mattress last?

On average, crib mattresses last between three to five years depending on the mattress, condition, and proper use. The mattress’ lifespan may change depending on whether or not it’s waterproof or mold resistant. It will also depend on the mattress’ materials and regular maintenance such as cleaning stains and using a crib mattress cover properly.

What are the best crib mattress materials to look for?

Look for crib mattresses specially designed and certified to help keep your baby safe during sleep. Organic mattresses are not always the best, but often include better materials to help reduce allergy symptoms, with chemically sensitive and environmentally-friendly materials. Look for crib mattresses that are CertiPUR-US certified to be free of lead, mercury, flame retardants and other harmful ingredients. CertiPUR-US crib mattresses are also tested to be durable. Other popular crib mattresses are also GREENGUARD Gold certified to meet special requirements for fewer VOCs and harmful chemicals.


Care Tips After Buying the Right Baby Mattress

With the right crib mattress, your baby can sleep well without worry of inhaling chemicals or other common concerns that parents have. You’ll know that your baby is getting rest with the right firm mattress needed for healthy bone development. But here are a few tips for proper care and the best sleep for your baby.  




  • Air out the mattress. When your baby’s crib mattress arrives, air it out for at least two days before using. Airing out the mattress reduces the common scent of a new mattress and releases any potentially harmful VOCs trapped in the mattress from the packaging.
  • Wipe away messes immediately. Spills and accidents often pose a sanitary concern if not cleaned up properly. Some spills include harmful bacteria and harsh chemicals that you don’t want your baby to breathe in. Follow your mattress care tips for wiping up stains without ruining the mattress. Remember to use a mattress cover or pad to catch stains for a quick and easy clean up.
  • Regularly clean the mattress. Vacuum the mattress to remove built-up dirt and dust that the eye may not see. You’ll also want to scrub away any stains and rinse the areas thoroughly. Lastly, disinfect the mattress regularly and leave time for it to air out before placing your baby back on the mattress to avoid breathing in harsh chemicals and harmful bacteria.
  • Rotate it regularly. To avoid one side of the mattress sinking or wearing long before the other side, rotate it regularly. You’ll avoid a lumpy or sunken mattress that might not be as comfortable or safe over time from using it on only one side. Start by rotating it every two weeks or follow your mattress provider’s recommendations.

As a parent, your baby’s safety is your number one priority. When shopping for the perfect mattress, remember to keep you and your baby’s needs top of mind. Start by browsing our recommendations and check out a full list of Amazon’s best selling crib mattresses to see all of the industry-leading options.

Disclaimer: While many crib manufacturers state their mattresses are free of chemicals and toxins, Safety.com cannot affirm this or any other claim from the manufacturer regarding the crib mattress. Our experts also cannot guarantee the safety of each crib mattress for infants or toddlers.